Hotel Passport Scans on the Dark Web? Why the Garante’s Alert Matters—and How Hotels Reduce Risk

Photo: Depositphotos

The Italian data protection authority (Garante) recently warned that several hotel IT systems were breached and high-resolution scans of passports and ID cards were stolen. Even when properties act quickly, these incidents highlight a structural problem in hospitality: front desks routinely create and store copies of the most sensitive identifiers a person has. Have you ever checked in and wondered why do we need to share our passport and put it on file indefinitely? This makes hotels prime targets for cyber-attacks and privacy risks.

There is a path to follow core privacy principles pioneered by the GDPR such as data minimization, purpose and storage limitation, lawful basis, data-subject rights, and accountability.

WHY HOTELS ARE PRIME TARGETS

• Hotels process a concentrated bundle of high-value identifiers: government IDs, payment tokens, home addresses, travel itineraries, and sometimes children’s data.
• Many properties still scan full passports/IDs at check-in to satisfy local rules, creating image files that, if exfiltrated, enable account takeovers, synthetic identity fraud, SIM swaps, and cross-border scams.
• Property-management systems (PMS), key-card systems, CRM, Wi-Fi portals, and vendor remote access often share networks—multiplying breach pathways.

THE LEGAL RISKS

Under GDPR, any compromise of personal data can trigger regulator notice within 72 hours and, when the risk to individuals is high, direct notice to guests. Hotels must be able to explain what data they hold, why they hold it, how long they keep it, what security protects it, and how they will remedy harm.

WHAT WENT WRONG—AND WHAT TO FIX NOW

1. Over-collection and long retention of ID images
   • Replace full-page scans with field extraction (only the legally required fields).
   • If a scan is unavoidable, crop to required zones, encrypt at rest, and delete within days—automatically.
2. Flat, legacy architectures and vendor sprawl
   • Segment ID images and payment tokens into separate, access-controlled vaults.
   • Enforce MFA for staff and vendors; disable shared accounts; monitor for bulk downloads.
3. Weak breach preparedness
   • Train front-desk and IT on an incident playbook: isolate, investigate, notify, and support guests.
   • Keep regulator templates and multilingual guest notices ready.

GDPR PRINCIPLES HOTELS CAN’T IGNORE

Data Minimization (collect only what you truly need)

• Check-in: capture only fields required by law or the booking. Avoid full-page ID copies unless statute explicitly requires them.
• Payments: tokenize cards; never store full PAN/CVV.
• Loyalty/marketing: keep separate, opt-in records; never repurpose identity documents for profiling.

Purpose Limitation (say what you’ll do—and only do that)

• Define specific purposes: legal registration, reservation and stay management, payments, security (e.g., CCTV), and separately consented loyalty/marketing.
• If you later want analytics or personalization beyond the original purpose, perform a compatibility assessment and obtain fresh consent where required.

Storage Limitation & Data Retention (set short, written schedules)

• Turn principles into a schedule enforced by automation:
• • ID images (if collected): delete within hours or a few days after mandatory verification.
  • Guest registration: retain only as long as local public-security rules require, then anonymize or delete.
  • Reservation and folio records: follow finance/tax rules; isolate invoices from identity documents.
  • CCTV: 24–72 hours by default; longer only for documented incidents.
  • Access/Wi-Fi logs: 30–90 days unless a specific security need exists.
  • Marketing/loyalty: remove inactive contacts on a set cadence and whenever consent is withdrawn.

Lawful Basis (map each process to the right legal ground)

• Legal obligation: police/immigration registration fields.
• Contract: reservation management, check-in/out, room preferences needed to perform the stay.
• Legitimate interests: proportionate security (CCTV, fraud prevention) after a balancing test and with opt-outs where appropriate.
• Consent: email/SMS marketing, third-party remarketing pixels, non-essential cookies. Use a consent management platform (CMP) like the one offered by Captain Compliance to collect, log, and enforce choices across web, app, and Wi-Fi portals. A fair warning about consent banners that don’t actually block cookies are coming under heavy scrutiny and it’s pertinent to make sure you use one of the few banner software solutions that actually block cookies and are integrated correctly.
• Special categories/biometrics: avoid unless a clear exemption applies; if used, require explicit consent or another valid ground plus heightened safeguards and a DPIA.

Data-Subject Rights (make it easy—and fast)

• Offer streamlined access, rectification, erasure, restriction, objection, and portability within one month.
• Verify identity without creating new ID copies (use ephemeral checks or masked comparisons).
• Search all systems: PMS, CRM, key-card logs, Wi-Fi, CCTV indices (if identifiable), marketing platforms, and vendor archives.
• Explain lawful retention limits (e.g., tax records) while removing or pseudonymizing everything else—especially ID images and logs.

Accountability (prove you did the right thing)

• Maintain a Record of Processing Activities (ROPA) for each hotel/brand and key vendors.
• Run DPIAs for high-risk processing (ID images, biometrics, extensive CCTV) and document legitimate-interest assessments.
• Train staff; enforce “no smartphone photos” of IDs; script DSAR and breach responses.
• Sign DPAs with vendors, include deletion SLAs, and test deletion with real tickets.
• Keep evidence: MFA everywhere, least-privilege access, tamper-evident logs, quarterly deletion reports, and minutes from breach drills.

ACTION PLAN FOR HOTEL GROUPS AND INDEPENDENTS

• Minimize the artifact: favor field extraction; if scans are mandatory, crop, encrypt, and auto-purge quickly.
• Harden entry points: MFA for PMS/OTAs/vendors; rotate credentials; monitor exfiltration patterns.
• Network and data segmentation: isolate ID images, payment vaults, and guest profiles; restrict egress to approved destinations.
• Vendor due diligence: require clear statements on ID handling, retention, and deletion; audit regularly.
• Breach drills and communications: pre-draft guest notices; align with regulatory content requirements; keep contact lists current.

WHAT TRAVELERS CAN DO

1. Ask whether the property stores a copy of your ID and for how long.
2. Offer alternatives (show but don’t copy; or allow only a cropped/MRZ capture if law allows).
3. Monitor your documents after a stay; if a breach involves IDs, consider renewing and set alerts for new accounts or SIM changes.

HOW THESE PRINCIPLES REDUCE BREACH FALLOUT

• Less data = lower blast radius.
• Clear lawful bases = clearer, faster notifications.
• Habitual deletion = smaller investigations and quicker recovery.
• Documented accountability = higher regulator confidence and reduced enforcement risk.

QUICK HOTEL CHECKLIST

1. Turn full-page ID scans off by default; if mandated, crop + encrypt + auto-delete within days.
2. Publish a plain-language retention schedule and wire it into the PMS/DAM with automated purges.
3. Separate legal-obligation data from marketing/loyalty; require opt-in for any remarketing cookies.
4. Map lawful bases per dataset; run DPIAs where risk is high.
5. Stand up a DSAR workflow with identity checks that don’t create new ID copies.
6. Prove accountability: ROPA up to date, vendor DPAs signed, deletion reports filed quarterly.

Treat IDs Like Crown Jewels

Hotel convenience cannot come at the cost of lifelong identifiers. Treat ID images like crown jewels: don’t create them unless you must, don’t keep them longer than necessary, and ring-fence them with modern controls. As I’ve covered recently data minimization should be your first control to prevent bigger issues down the road. When something goes wrong, move quickly, communicate clearly, and show your paper trail. For many brands, a certified consent and preference platform (for example, Captain Compliance) helps centralize consent, retention, and DSAR intake across websites and Wi-Fi portals while creating the audit trail you’ll need during investigations or breach follow-ups.

Richart Ruddie
Founder of Captain Compliance
Captain Compliance

Information TechnologySafety & Security

Please visit:

Our Sponsor